- galaxies.:
- I don't think people are really posting on this thread with the expressive intent to discuss why they dislike the bands.
Which I know, I know, it sounds kind of silly when I put it out there, but yeah.
Why post on a discussion thread if you don't want to discuss it? Well I myself, while open to the idea of talking about why I don't like a band I don't like, don't necessarily like to discuss it with a fan of the band because I always feel like I'm coming off as rude. 
But, no, you're right. You two were respectful about it. I mean, yes, if they're outright bashing the band (and by bashing I mean 'THIS BAND SUCKS HARD, I THINK THE LEAD SINGER NEEDS TO GO DIE, etc), I think that's reason enough to step in. But otherwise, why even make a comment? People have already said things about no one liking band x. Perhaps I'm just a pessimistic sort of person, but I can see all sorts of bad feelings coming out of this thread. I've seen fans of the same band attack each other on Mibba. People can get pretty defensive/offensive about music on the boards, which I completely understand. Just saying.
/non-confrontational!anneh is non-confrontational 
....I feel like I was a little all over the place with that one.
Bad train of thought, anyone?
I can understand that, but at the same time- I think the entire idea of this thread could cause some people to get defensive and offensive about their favorite bands, y'know? That could just be the way that I see it, but who knows?
I feel that if there's more discussion about why said bands are disliked, as opposed to just saying THAT they're disliked, it could make for good conversation. Other people seeing each other's points of view could make them less defensive, I guess.
Could just be my curiousity, but I get curious as to why people don't like certain bands. It's not me trying to be rude or cause fights, I'm just interested in knowing.
And I do understand where you're coming from about fans of Green Day getting attacky. I think if people were to go into attack mode about it, there'd be a problem. But as I've said before, I think this thread in general can cause some emotions to run high... so I think maybe saying 'I dislike this band for this reason' is a way to keep them under control. But that could just be differing points of view on both of our behalfs.
- la nuit belge.:
Like this. I can respect that. It doesn't offend me. It doesn't seem like anything worth arguing over. Some people don't like my favorite band, and that's fine. Since I do love Green Day so much, I like to hear the reasons why people don't, because usually- I can't understand what there is about them to dislike.
I'm not interested in arguing with anyone over it, just curious as to the reasons why. I may disagree, but I'm not going to get offended.