@ CallusedSilk
It really grates on me. I mean, I can play Wonderwall (I don't think there's a guitarist on the planet that
can't play Wonderwall, it's one of the first songs everyone at my uni admits to learning) but I don't ever play it seriously. I play it to irritate my friends - again, it irritates them because no one but Oasis should play it as a serious song.
Totally agree with your comment about gritty voices as well. It's part of the reason why I mildly dislike Panic! at the Disco's cover of
Tonight, Tonight. Brendon's voice is too sugary to pull off the song, especially since Billy Corgan's voice is so gritty and...I don't want to say nasty because I actually love his voice, but I have no other word to describe it. It lost a lot of the original flair when the vocals were perfect and as much as I love Brendon's voice, it ruined the cover for me.