Come Out of the Shade is my highest rated one-shot, with seven stars, 308 readers, ten subscribers and eleven comments. I still don't understand how it got so popular; it's an original femmeslash about friends with benefits, it's not exactly the kind of thing a lot of people read.
Just reached 10 stars today! I was amazed (and friggin' excited!) when I saw it. It's been posted on the site for two and a half years and it's the first of any of my stories to have reached ten stars.