- hephaestus:
- Why can't the thing that makes them beautiful make them better hunters? The whole point of them being beautiful is to attract prey, so yes, it does make them love-objects. That's just it, it isn't reality. It's a story. There are no rules that say that Meyer had to stick to the myth of the vampire.
But I didn't
say that beauty wouldn't make them better hunters. I said that I didn't think that was the
reason they were beautiful. Edward and the rest of the Cullens aren't hunters - it's said many, many times that they're scary and dangerous but all that's ever proved is that they like to talk about how scary and dangerous they are. They're love-objects. Pretty, smelly love-objects. There's nothing
wrong with that, but that is very much how it looks.
- hephaestus:
- The science behind the sparkling, as I've said, is that it helps them attract prey. This is Meyer's science behind it. I don't really know how else to explain it.
I mean biologically and chemically why do they sparkle - she claimed that they were scientific creatures, I would like to know how. I get that every pretty thing about them is to "attract prey" (especially prey in the form of six-year-old girls, one would assume).
- hephaestus:
- But Meyer isn't Kelley Armstrong. She didn't think that a vampire could be moral if it was going around murdering people. Do you?
Yes. But my point was that Armstrong's vampires were different from the original myths too, and are beautiful and awesome cool, but still incorporate enough of the original idea to pass as a vampire. And they have weaknesses, which is also nice.
- hephaestus:
- This may be true but I don't see how it takes away from the validity of my post.
Older vampires could hunt without these things but Stephenie wanted something different and that's what she created. She didn't just "make something up" because that's not what she wanted to do. It is in fact her fantasy. She should be able to write about what she wants instead of having to make up a completely different creature just to avoid breaking the "rules" of Vampirism.
She can do whatever the heck she likes. You asked why I didn't like the vampires in Twilight, I told you.
- The Fantasy:
- I really don't get the point in debating about the changes Stephenie made with her vampires.
Questions were asked, answers were given. That's basically the point. If people want to like Meyer's vampires then they're more than welcome to. Doesn't bother me particularly.