April 22nd, 2009 at 08:22pm
Oh my gosh I can't believe that this is the end!
What I really love about your writing is your juxtaposing, like the sunny weather against Charley's foul mood. I love it because it's not clique at all, usually when the lead girl is sad it's raining buckets and the like.
tainted with a brush of loneliness I adore that sentence, it's so honest and you really can get a clear feel for her emotions. But what I like about it is how it shows that Charley is determined not to let her situation bring her down, it's as if it's happened to her before. Which is obviously very sad but the fact that she gets out there and carries on doing her thing, shows she's very strong and admirable.
What also has to be said for this story is how flawlessly you move in and out of character perspectives. It happens so smoothly and I really think that speaks out for your strength as a writer, that you can write amazingly well from other perspectives.
I had a giggle at the description of the boys sitting in the van and trying to drown out each others singing. Nick is obviously looking to be distracted but it's really sweet how it's not working out at all for him, and then YAY he turns around! God bless his friends for being so understanding :tehe: I bet Eric is secretly jealous :XD
I like it how both Nick and Charley think back to the time when they both stopped off at the wishing well, it's really telling of their affections and also shows that they are on the same brain length :tehe:
I love how Nick and Charley meet again in the same way as the did before their relationship/friendship formed. It's such a sweet idea and shows how they have both come full circle and how manybe everything was just meant to be.
But seriously AMAZING last line! It ties in SO well with everything you told us about the shop windows, how people notice and at the same time don't notice things. I really love that idea because Nick and Charley are very much real within your story, it shows that the best things in life are those which actually happen, not like the mannequins who aren't real and don't move. Does this even make sense?
Totally beautiful way of ending it, couldn't have been more perfect Laura. If you do decide to write a sequel let me know. Seriously amazing stuff Laura
xxx
Thirteen
I loved the opening, as always. It's all peaceful and relaxed and it's like the calm before the storm. The air smelt fresh, a gentle breeze drifted through the open window, it mixed with the sweet yet anonymous scent of the air freshener that had been sprayed around the room. The description was just...amazing, to put it lightly. I think that was some of your best writing ever, in my opinion.
I liked how you made a big thing of her good mood. She had danced around her apartment all morning, cleaning. It's obvious that it's all to do with Nick, and it just gives the story such a happy feel, knowing that Charley finally feels a sense of belonging and worth. I think that's an important thing for her and I'm glad that Nick was able to show it her.
Nick's feelings for Charley are very realistic. He had regretted it almost instantly, but at the same time he was glad he'd made that move. He regretted helping her clear out, but knew that if he hadn't, things might not be the way that they were now. And deep down inside himself I don't think he minds what he does, as long as it's with Charley. It shows how deep his feelings have really got for her.
I liked the friendly argument between them. "You're not that famous, Nick. You're in a small time band. You're hardly The Beatles are you?" This made me giggle and the way she put it just made me smile, because she knew she'd be able to get away with it. :tehe: And I love how Nick's all optimistic about his band.
I like it when Nick and Eric are together. :tehe: "Chuck did not beat me up!" Nick protested, still not moving from his lazy position on the sofa. They're like two children, constantly squabbling, but at the same time they come across as two very close individuals. They seem to know one another really well and Nick comes across as a person who makes a lot of effort when it comes to friendship and relationships.
And then things start to fall apart, and the relaxed atmosphere suddenly diminishes. She chewed her lip, tears forming in her eyes. "For how long?" She's trying to stop herself from crying, trying to stop herself from being upset, but she can't help it because of how much Nick means to her. And she takes it out on Nick, which is sad. It's like all the barriers that he broke have been put back up again, and it's like they're back to square one again.
Fourteen
Perfect ending, I'd just like to state that before I continue. :tehe: You finished it perfectly, leaving it slightly open - the problem of him going on tour still stands - and I love open endings rather than when they're all tied up :XD It lets the reader make up their mind about what happens later on.
It was sad how it started, with Charley feeling alone. Charley had woken up, her good mood tainted with a brush of loneliness. She's got used to Nick being around, and now that he's not with her any more she feels even more alone than she did when she started - because before she met Nick, she'd accepted her loneliness. I think this hurts her a lot that Nick is going.
I liked how things didn't really go to plan throughout the whole story, and this sums things up completely. As much as she hated to admit it, her wish at the wishing fountain had failed her. I liked that line, it's like she's not living in a fairytale and that things like wishing wells don't really work. :tehe:
I've got to admit that the next bit was a little hard to follow because the two parts weren't divided. Like, it went straight from Charley to Nick sat in the van, and for a moment I got confused and thought Charley was in the van and going on tour with them. I'm glad she didn't though, 'cause that's an awfully cliche thing to do. :lmfao
This was good. Nick was going to miss the unpredictability of his days with Charley. It shows how different each day was to them, and that what they had was exciting and new.
I love how knowing Eric is, and it shows how much he really knows Nick. Eric raised one dark eyebrow in thought. "We're going to the mall, aren't we?" He just says it without so much as a second thought, and it's obvious that he really knows his friend well, in order to be able to read him like that. It was very clever how you wrote him, I think Eric is my favourite character in the whole story :XD
I dunno why but this made me laugh. Nick and Eric and a couple of other people she had never met before were standing amongst the mannequins. They're in the exact place that she doesn't expect them to be, and the fact they were standing amongst the mannequins is pretty significant because it's like they're mannequins themselves, except that they're living. Damn, I can't get across the point I want to. It made sense in my head.
The ending was perfect. Nick lowered his face, meeting Charley's in the middle, the pair locked in a short, yet sweet kiss. And that was the best window display in the entire shopping centre. It was all smushy and sweet, and I actually grinned when I read it. It was the perfect way to end it so I salute you for that. :XD
I loved this story, right from the start to finish.
Sorry I wasn't prompt at leaving feedback though. I never seem to leave it on time. :tehe:
:arms: