What Did I Do to Deserve This? - Comments

  • still a secret

    still a secret (100)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    34
    Location:
    Philippines
    story review game

    summary
    “Her name [is] Lillith Anne Summers. She [was] my confidant, my colleague, the person I trusted more than anyone else. Most importantly, she [is] my best friend.”
    - stick to just one tense

    hit & runs!
    - was this intentional? It sounds a little strange to me. Maybe it should be “hit & run!” or “hits & runs!” instead

    “Course log entry #34”
    - the transition here from narration to whatever this is is not smooth, like it's a little confusing. What is this course log thing? Is it a journal?

    “They just stared [a t] me and I stared back.”
    - there's a space when there shouldn't be

    “"We never heard of where you came from until you got here," pointed out the other guy.”
    - who was he talking to here? clarify

    “The girl, Lillith, was making breakfast while [they] guys, Dakota and Gavin, sat waiting by the island.”
    - “the”

    “About a month before prom, me and her were eating lunch. Laughing, talking, being girls.”
    - this should just be one sentence

    “Her wavy brunette hair bounced [as] jumped up and down, pumping her fists in the air.”
    - “and”

    “They looked each other in the eyes and together, [they brought Hayley] back home.”
    - aren't there only two of them? Just Lillith and Hayley?

    “Both of the young entrepreneurs had been diagnosed with bipolarness [ahaha].”
    - What's with the sudden informalness? It's very distracting and sticks out like a sore thumb.

    I think this is an okay idea for a story. I just felt like the end wasn't built up too well. The setting should have been described before they died because they could be anywhere. I imagined that they were fighting indoors, not in a car, so when that other car came, I was more confused than worried, and you want your readers to be worried for the characters. So, the end is what needs the most work.
    April 5th, 2010 at 07:11am