I'm not a big Glee fan, but this was actually really good.
I absolutely ADORE "Faithfully". It tends to irritate me when people put the lyrics in like you did (even more so with songs that I have strong feelings about), but it didn't in this case. You blended them in well.
Anyway, this story was so good! I love how you wrote it, and put in the lyrics in the right places. I loved the storyline, and how it all played out, and especially the ending. It was extremely good.
I like Glee, I've watched every episode, at least I think... I just don't understand why Puck's name is Noah. Is Puck just his nickname because of his last name, or did you just decide to change his name to Noah? I'm confuzzeled. Haha:)
I absolutely ADORE "Faithfully". It tends to irritate me when people put the lyrics in like you did (even more so with songs that I have strong feelings about), but it didn't in this case. You blended them in well.
You did a good job. :]