February 18th, 2012 at 05:12pm
Chapter 1:
I love the description of the café, “Pieces of furniture were scattered around the room, attempting to make it seem random, but I knew the manager had forced his employees to meticulously place every armchair at a certain angle to make it look good from all sides”. The language was excellent and effortless.
Unfortunately, you lose the flow nearing the middle. As soon as Michaela receives the text, the story becomes rushed, which contrasts negatively with the descriptive, eloquent beginning. Try to downplay irrelevant scenes and dramatize the central ones.
I don’t think that you’ve noticed this, but you switch from past tense to present tense continuously.
Chapter 2:
Your language wasn’t very profound in this chapter.
You see, this:
"You look amazing...!" i said with a hint of laughter in my voice.
"What was the hint of laughter for?" she said this in an angry sort of way.
Could become this:
“You look amazing!” I said, a hint of laughter seeping into my voice.
Her eyes narrowed suspiciously. “What’s so funny?”
Try not to repeat lines! I know it’s difficult to find the right words sometimes; however the thesaurus is a brilliant tool. Trust me; I use it nearly every day. Also, reading novels that are genuinely well written helps widen the vocabulary, which, in turn, allows us to write more fluently.
The dialogue was a little underdeveloped. When Kyle was experiencing the effects of the drugs, you didn’t provide a very in depth description. You need to show rather than tell.
Chapter 3:
You’ve really redeemed yourself here. Currently your story is a rollercoaster. One minute we’re sliding towards the heavens, the next we’re plunging into the ground. With this chapter, you’re taking me higher and higher. Beautiful description throughout the entire chapter, you haven’t wavered.
You’ve really managed to make the reader empathise with Michaela. I feel as though her pain is my own.
Who is Josh? Kyle’s mysterious brother. I’m intrigued.
Chapter 4
Isn’t she a little young to be hanging out at a nightclub? If she snuck in, shouldn’t she at least be thinking about that a little?
That is all.
Chapter 5
You’ve definitely improved from Chapter 1 and 2. You have a broader vocabulary and your sentences are smooth with an even pace throughout the chapter. You haven’t rushed anything and you’ve taken time to describe her emotions and reveal the reason that she has taken solace in Josh.
“Unfortunately, my life doesn’t always turn out how I want it to.” A lovely ending for a lovely chapter.
I don't know about the layout, so I set it to default, and read. I feel so bad that the story opens on such a sad note. I mean, everything seems good, and then BAM! Kyle's death is dropped on us, much like it was dropped on her. It made it very shocking and realistic. I love the writing style, and the styles really blend together and that's what make's for a successful co-write. I'm going to subscribe. I'm interested. Josh is Kyle's brother? I think this is going to play out dramatically, and I am pretty stoked. Also, like, Kyle and the heroin? I know he's dead, but I want to know more about it. Was it his first time? Does Michaela know? Will she ever? SO many questions! I really like this, though. :)