June 4th, 2011 at 11:27pm
Chapter 1 - It's a bit too short for my liking and I think it should be in the summary rather than the first chapter. But, the part you mentioned that J-Dog likes to pay for hookers for unknown reasons just makes me laugh. I don't know why but it makes me laugh.
Chapter 2 - This chapter made me smile. It's so J3T. ^_^
Chapter 3 - Again, for unknown reason I laughed. This time when J3T suddenly screamed when they were in the hospital. And the cliffhanger at the end of the chapter is a nice hook to make me wonder what exactly happened.
Chapter 4 - Aww... the guys are just nice. Charlie just seemed kinda calm even though he knew someone was pretending to be him. If it were me, I know I'd at least scream and kick around. But, that's because I have short temper.
Chapter 5 - Erm... it's a bit unrealistic. For one, they don't just meet a random girl who's been beaten up on the street and take her on tour with them. But, well, it's what keeps this story moving.
Chapter 6 - I have nothing to say on this chapter.
Chapter 7 - That's a nice twist.
Chapter 8 - Wow, Johnny sure was calm even though he'd just found out he'd made a girl pregnant.
Chapter 9 - She killed herself? Wow!
General - I find it weird that you use their stage name in the story. I think it'll be more realistic if they use their real name when they're interacting with one another. It's okay if they use their stage name among their fans. Until the end of the story, I'm wondering who's the guy that pretended to be Charlie. I'm sorry, but I think this story is flat. It has no real plot or whatever. But, you are a good writer. I mean, I don't find any major grammar or spelling mistakes and you can go far. Just keep on writing.
Gosh, I feel like the worst commenter in the history. I like this story and I think it has potential. I'm just a bit disappointed with the ending and there are just too many loose threads. I'm going to stop now. Anyway, I'm not trying to be mean.
I'm actually a HUGE fan of surprise endings, especially ones as fucked up as this, so yeah, I really liked it. And really, man, I didn't see it coming for shit!
Also, it was really surprising how Kristyn was pregnant with Johnny's baby.
But now I feel like there are so many unanswered questions! What was up with the dude that was wearing Charlie's clothes? Who the fuck is this Kristyn chick and why did she end up so crazy? And of course, how can the band possibly continue after this?
That's why I'd really fucking love for you to write a follow-up story to this. Not only because I'm not ready for the story to end, but because I think there soooo much more you can do with it. Put simply, you've got a wonderfully creative mind & I wanna see you put it to get use.
So yes, please write more! I would definitely read the shit out of it! <3