Annabelle should have just told Jared that instead of messing it up. I like how she told her dad everything, but he didn't believe her. It sounds too ridiculous to believe.
I hope they don't tell Tim what really happened because I feel as if he'll flip out. Also, what was up with Annabelle trying to be nice to Jared? Seriously Annabele, you already messed that one up and don't deserve Jared.