This Is How It's Supposed to Be.

I could see it in Garrett’s eyes that he was going to say yes. Despite the tension filling the air, and despite the glares coming from everyone in the yard, he was going to say yes and let her come to exclusively male-and-Caleb bonfire, effectively breaking what would be the sixth year of this tradition. He was crossing an imaginary line that we’d all made an unspoken agreement to not cross.

Based loosely on You Belong With Me by Taylor Swift.