It's Too Late to Catch Me Now

After breaking up with Quinn Fabray for Rachel, Finn expected the girl to run into his arms. After all, hadn't she loved him for two years now? He finally wanted her again, she should be thrilled.

Of course, seeing her kiss Jesse St. James on the stage was a minor setback, but he didn't concern himself with it too much. He had won her from Jesse before, he could do it again. He set his plans for New York and waited.

And now he's going to win her back once and for all. In New York, with St. James not around, he knows he can do it.

Or can he? Fate may have other things in mind. Is Finn just being overconfident? Or is it actually true love?

Note: This is ANTI-Finchel, and AU ending to the season 2 finale. It's a One Shot Songfic based on Taylor Swift's song White Horse. I don't want to deal with ship wars, so if you have a huge problem with any ship other than Finchel please don't read this. It's just a story. :)