Falling for the Teacher Is Never a Good Idea

I had a key. What do people do with keys? Unlock doors. I was standing in front of a door. The key I was holding belonged to that door. I knew I should probably unlock the door.

It took me a minute to build up the strength, but I put the key in the lock and twisted my wrist.

The sound of water was the first thing I heard as the shower was running behind the bathroom door, so I closed the front door behind me, and just kind of stood there.

I didn’t have to wait long before Cas, wearing a towel loosely around his waist, exited and almost jumped at the sight of me standing there.

“Um hi there?” Cas said, but he didn’t have time to say much of anything else, as I quickly and easily pushed him against the wall and started furiously kissing him.

So far from the other times we’d kissed, Cas had taken a minute or two for him to slip his tongue into my mouth, though he was always the first to do so, but this kiss is very different. My tongue was in his mouth within seconds, and though I was usually gentle, I barely even madea an attempt as I just attacked Cas’ lips with dire urgency.

Cas didn’t complain as his hands wrapped themselves around my neck not allowing me to pull away from the kiss even if I tried. Cas didn’t know exactly what was going on but he didn’t care. He probably thought of himself as the ‘dom’, but tonight is the night for setting aside the expected and making room for the new.

Cas and I managed to pull away from the bathroom door, but as soon as the door was closed, Cas pushed me against it kissing me heatedly, and I felt both himself and I becoming more and more turned on.

I had expected that ambushing Cas would mean I’d take the lead but I was sorely mistaken but I was even more turned on by this bossy Cas than maybe I should’ve been.

Cas pulled my shirt off with ease and attacked my lips once again, biting gently on the lower one which made me moan into his mouth. Cas was extremely cavalier as well with the fact that he was definitely not fooled with what we were leading up to as he unzipped and pushed my pants down as best as he could, until I tugged them off easily and threw them to the side.

I easily pulled off Cas’ towel exposing his erect cock, and pulled away long enough to look at him.

“Holy fuck,” I said.

“What?” Cas asked.

“You’re beautiful,” I said, not lying and looking completely gleeful with this discovery.

Cas bit his lip again seductively then pulled away and the look in his eye was of pure lust while his expression looked devilish.

Cas kissed down my neck, chest and stomach, stopping at my hip bone and nudging his fingers under the hem of my boxers until he pulled them down and I stepped out of them.

Cas looked up at me, as he settled on his knees and took my shaft in his hand.

“Oh god,” I said, my head falling back against the door, making Cas smile excitedly. Cas teased me for a couple seconds licking along my length and swirling his tongue around the head, as I tried my hardest not to beg him.

Finally he put me into his mouth, a little at first, and then more, which made me take a sharp gasp. Cas took more and more of me into his mouth until his mouth couldn’t hold anymore as I put my face is in my hands.

When Cas realized he couldn’t fit anymore of my cock in his mouth he started to get a little faster and faster until I was slick with pre-cum and spit.

“Oh god, fuck!” I said, full of elation. I grabbed Cas’ hair slightly and forced him to move faster.

“Cas, oh fuck! I’m going to cum!” I screamed feeling myself ready to climax, but Cas kept going faster until I couldn’t take it anymore and screamed again, “Cas, I’m going to cum!” He pulled away soon enough as I cummed slightly on his chin and down his chest, but he just licked it off, and stood up slightly to kiss me again.

I let him kiss me, not as heatedly, but still passionately for a few seconds before I said to him, “I’m going to make you feel that good.”

Cas smiled sweetly, and said, “You can if you want, just let me kiss you first.”

Cas kissed me for several minutes, his hard on brushing against my leg until I could barely take it anymore. I pushed him forward and backward onto the bed firmly, then climbed on top of him, and smothered him with a kiss.

“Turn over,” I whispered into Cas’ ear after nibbling it for a second.

Cas pulled me by the neck and snogged me then said, “I have some lube... nightstand.”

“Okay,” I replied, and even though Cas wanted to be embarrassed he just turned over as asked, as I carefully slicked up a finger and tenderly prodded Cas’ hole.

“Is this alright?” I asked.

“Oh god yes,” Cas replied, making me grin and put my finger a little further in. Cas winced but assured me he was okay, and to keep going so I added another finger, and when I was confident enough that Cas’ hole would allow it, I slicked myself and gently inserted myself into him.

“Oh Fuck, Dean,” he whispered, closing his eyes, as I pushed in a little further, and a little further still.

“Oh god,” he said, as I pulled out a little and then back in.

“Are you okay?” I asked cautiously as I pushed in again.

“Yes! Yes, faster,” He ordered, and I did, bit by bit going faster until all of me was buried in Cas, and he gasped out my name.

I thrust into Chim faster and faster and watched Cas’ hands tighten as he shouted my name, and it struck me how weird it was that I was making him feel that way.

“Oh god, Dean!” He said, and his breathing started becoming unimportant as all he cared about was me inside of him.

I could feel Cas push me over from where I was and I fell onto my back.

Cas climbed on top of me at this and for a second he looked down at me, biting his lip and then leisurely yet surely lowered himself back down onto my erect member.

“Oh fu-,“ he said, barely even in a whisper as his head fell back and he brought his hands to his head.

Cas recovered easily but I melted at seeing him so vulnerable for a minute, and I watched Cas gently at first, but then pick up speed as he bounced on my cock.

I grabbed Cas’ hips to help him keep his balance and I couldn’t help but stare at his face. Cas had a beautiful face in any situation but never one more amazing than the one he was making then which was of ecstasy and mirth. His cheeks were red, and his eyes were screwed up in determination but that all combined to make me fall even more for the man than I already was.

Cas didn’t even have time to warn me before he climaxed and I felt him cum across my stomach, making us both scream each other’s names.

Cas just collapsed there, on top of me, his head falling onto my shoulder, and his hands caressing through my hair. His was still wet from the shower but I didn’t really mind.

“You know I’m starting to consider whether dating a teacher might actually be a good idea,” I said, my chest heaving under Cas’.

Cas lifted his head up a little bit, and giggled, “You think?”

“I actually do. Just a thought, I guess,” I replied.

“Oh just kiss me,” Cas said, in response, and because my bones were filled with exhaustion it didn’t take much for him to be able to push me squarely on the back and kiss me.

“Do you think we can do this?” Cas asked, looking down at me, a little scared.

“Yeah, I think so,” I answered, and he smiled happily.

“What about Dick?”

“I don’t see why it’s any of his business, especially since I’ll never see him again after June.”

“As long as I have you,” he whispered softly.

“You do.”

I fell asleep not long after, and I think for the first time I knew one hundred percent what it was that I wanted. I wanted Cas.