Status: 2019.
Amber Alert
She asked innocently "Do you know what it's like to kill someone?"
It was just a hypothetical question that she didn't realize she would get an answer to.
With a straight face he answers "Yes I do."
Phoebe had been gone for 28 days but no one was counting at this point. Her parents have accepted that she was running away from her problems and wouldn't be coming back. They never could've thought that she was dead.
Meanwhile Nicole was living with guilt at what had occurred. Phoebe was her sister and now she was gone. Phoebe was gone and it was all because of her.