Let's Be Hypothetical Here

(This might change as the story goes along becasue i'm not the only one writing this story.)
*The Telephone Game - A contest started by MusicalMasochist which entitles contestants to write the next chapter of the story they chose. This is one of those stories.

Johnathon Bishop and Gareth Peters have been friends since they were six. They do everything together or at the same time. They even found out they were gay at the same time. They found out that Johnathon likes it rough with the other guy on top together. They found out the Gareth's better at giving it than taking it together. They also found out that they'd both rather be together than with anyone else.

"Oh...my god. I love that," Gareth panted, as he rolled off me, snuggling into my chest.

"Damn straight. It can't get any better than that," I laughed, wrapping my arm around his midsection.

"Johnathan, can I tell you something?" he asked, looking up at me, flipping some sweat-drenched hair out of his eyes.

"Of course,"

"What if, hypothetically speaking, I said I loved you? And, what if, hypothetically speaking, of course...I wasn't being hypothetical?"