New Story? Please Help

Ok so I've had a plot to a new story for awhile now in my head and I just can't seem to decide who should be in it as the main character besides an OC. It's between Shawn Milke from Alesana, Oli Sykes from BMTH, Craig Mabbitt from ETF, Ben Bruce from Asking Alexandria(he's so freaking adorable!) Kenneth Nixon from Framing Hanley, Ville Valo ;) from HIM, either Gerard or Frankie from MCR(not a slash), Ryan Ross from P!ATD, Jacoby Shaddix from Papa Roach, either Mike or Jaime from Pierce The Veil, Micheal or David from Vampires Everywhere!, and lastly a Jimmy, Brian, or Zacky from Avenged Sevenfold. Leave a comment to who you think should be in my new story, it will be greatly appreciated! :) and don't worry my other story "Lost In Your Lies" won't be neglected!