Untangle Me Mr. Right

You know that when I hate you, it is because I love you to a point of passion that unhinges my soul. -Julie de Lespinasse.

You know when you make a new friend, and you immediately know you want to be best friends forever with that person? I love that feeling.
Immediately after becoming best friends, you swear to never get into fights, or split over petty things like boys. Well that's what we girls do.
What do you do when your best friend is a boy?

Remy was a hard catch.
John was after every girl, and every girl was after him. Except the one he wanted.
Nick, well Nick has what John wants.

♀♥♀ Remy

♂♥♂ John O'callghan V
♂♥♂ Nicholas Santino

Title Credit goes to two of my favorite bands.
The Maine and A Rocket to the Moon.
The Maine: Fold your Hands Child (Untangle Me)
A Rocket to the Moon: Mr. Right.
Both singers are part of the story, why not incorporate both?