I was about 5 at the time. I remember seeing him in magazines and thinking he was really cute. Then I saw Titanic when I was 7 and that's when my crush on him really took off. XD
I'm not into him as much anymore (at least not as much as I was back then), but there's still a little something there every time I see him in a movie or a magazine.
Johnathan Taylor Thomas until I was like 11. Dear Lord, I was in love with that boy. I fell for him when he was in Pinocchio when I was like four. I named my first dog after him.