How to Write a Review

^
I review as I read as well. If I'm leaving a comment, I do the same thing, just not so much in depth. If you review as you read, then the review doesn't seem as daunting because you're doing it a little bit at a time.

I think a good review will obviously point out any grammatical errors and the like. It will also point out any plot holes or any points in the story that don't fit a character's personality or motives the way it had been written before. I think a good review also takes the time to make inferences about what's to come or hidden things that may have happened or could be interpreted differently.