The character was based around the character of Elijah from the vampire diaries, actually. I couldn't help it. I had another picture and description picked out for my character and thought I'd be happy with just the name Elijah, but every time I wrote about him, I pictures Daniel Gillies and eventually I gave in and used his pic. But he's not a vampire, so it's not a fanfic technically.
Thank you so much for your comment on AGMD! I've, er, actually never watched John Tucker Must Die (come to think of it, I've never even read the Wikipedia page for it...), so differences from the film are mainly because of my ignorance rather than ~creativity and whatnot, haha. That said, it's pretty great you have the same name/personality as her because I really, really suck at getting my characters to sound like actual people. Again, thank you, and I hope you keep reading. :)