I really loved the phrase "vintage tear-stains." It's something I've never heard before, but I can tell exactly what you meant. The poem does have a certain sense of nostalgia to it, and I really liked it. It was short but sweet. Very beautiful :)
Dude, this was beautiful. I don't really read poems much, but this was just... so amazing. I love especially the sentence "Feeling like a counterfeit, an imposter". I have nothing constructive to say. Only Bravo.