Album Analysis: American Idiot - Comments

Hey. I didn't feel like you actually reviewed the album. Instead, I felt like you only told about the meaning behind the songs. As a review, you just wrote a # out of #.

This is a great review!! :) Have you checked out American Idiot: the musical? It's amazing. It got me into Green Day, actually. It features most (I think all) of the American Idiot album, some songs from 21st Century Breakdown, and a couple of non-album songs too. I think you'd really like it :D

This perfectly described the utter art and complexity involved in the making of American Idiot. It is a true masterpiece, and I loved the review!

That's odd... my album of American Idiot has more songs then that...

we said forever? there's album reviews for albums way older than American Idiot...

Anyway, American Idiot got a 82% on your review, in my country's grading system that's an A for high school, and a Distinction for university. Not bad.

I enjoyed reading this review, and agree (mostly) with the 'grades' given.

Hahaha, you're a little late with reviewing this album.
Regardless, you did a nice job(:
I remember when I used to like Green Day.

I remember when i had first listened to Green Day. they were the first band i ever listened to also. i never knew the meanings behind any of the lyrics until now. and yet i know ever song word for word. well isnt that a bit sad? xD oh well. very nice article! and thank you for clarifying the songs for me. ^-^

I enjoyed reading this you did a Great job

This is their only CD where I like more than one song on it

Awesome!! Can't waitt to see itt!!!!!!!

Even if it was their "sell-out" point, I don't care. It's still a good album.

v Agreed.

This is a summary/review, not an analysis.

My favorite ablum so far :-)

AMERICAN IDIOT. ♥

My third favourite Green Day album behind Nimrod and Dookie. :3

[b]iMMa.Start.A.riOt[/b]
I've actually got one in the works. I'm gonna work my way through all of the albums that I like.

You should do one on 21st Century breakdown.

Love Green Day. Love the album. Love the article. I agree with most of the grades. Very well written.