I heard this movie was a waste of his talent, so I didn't borther to go see it (which I was supposed to today with my dad). I was disappointed with The Village and that was made out to be one of his best movies until it actually came out. I saw that movie before I read the reviews and wish I read them first.
My favorites will always be Signs and the Sixth Sense. I think he's just having a hard time coming up with really good ideas. Lady In The Water was okay, but not fantastic.