Liar - Comments

Wow, that was such a heartbreaker. The way you gave Bob and the reader hope at the final moment only to have us all crushed to pieces by Mikey's words.


It was really sweet and Bob's love was so pure and beautiful. The way Mikey was described just made me wanna grab them both and make them kiss. Screw the limits! there are no limitations unless you set them yourself and that's just stupid to do! Mikey could have been Bob's, I just know it.
Mikey should be Bob's.

Thanks for showing me this :arms:
It definitely made me love Bob even more

lol. See, I had to force myself to not think it was Frank at the beginning. Everytime I imagined Frank's voice telling the story, I slapped myself (well, not literally) and said ''Focus, Lupi! Focus!!''.. It was obvious that it wasn't Gee 'cause it didn't jump into the ''oh, this is wrong, I'm going to hell, blah blah'' thing. And then, the press conference. I have to say, that desert island video is one of my favorite MCR videos ever, and when you said ''moving the mic so I could talk'' I literally yelled ''BOB!!!!'' -_-* Poor Bob. I KNOW what it's like to watch someone you love walk away with somebody else... It's not nice.

SO, 1734982759847539 mexican cookies for you :D

Bad Sruti. Bad, bad, bad Sruti! xD
You made me cry! That was so well written and your first person narrative is awesome for all I can see.
I could totally see it all. And I cried like a freakin' baby.
Another sucky comment today. Sorry about that. Oo
This story was amazing.
Even if it was only a oneshot.

Aww. Thank you.

And it's cool I fooled you! *feels cool*

At first I thought it was Gerard...and then I thought Ray.
haha. This is awesome.

oooh we loved it!! <33
and well we knew it was bob coz you told us before but we prob wouldve got it round the whole TPing the Times Square bit

Louise + Eriko
xoxoxoxox

wow...I suck at guessing. Right at the summary I was like 'its frank'
And then when it said 'bob' I was like "WTF?"
Butt Okay So I really liked it. I didn't think it was crap. I liked how you kept the identity hidden until almost the end. *claps*

<33 katie

oh wait just read someone elses comment and now im editing this *facepalm*

OF course it was bob!!!!! The TP-ing. How could I have missed that?
okay i'll stop now

squee~ kyah~

bikey luff :D

it was amazing. I love it :D

You pwn me so bad.

I jumped out of my seat when I read that name.

And...ow, wow. That was just amazing.

Loved the description of Mikey.

i saw the TP bit and was like "holy hell tis BOBBLES!" thought it was ray at first teehee really awesome work!

aww. Thanks you guys. :hug:

lyrical_mess:

:tehe:

I'm glad I managed to fool someone. No one saw the toilet paper thing? It's hilarious.

I saw it! as soon as I saw that bit in the story i'm like omg it's bob! lol

loved the story

That was soo sad
It was reallly well written.

That was soo sweet! Thought it was Frankie at first, people always seem to make Frankie and Gerard the one's in love with other band members, but it was pretty obvious it wasn't Gerard! I didn't know it was Bob until the toilet paper bit! But that wasn't in LOTMS, cos it was only last year.
You made me have to watch that and the album press interview thingy again!
Great story!

Actually, a soon as you mentioned the toilet paper part, I knew it was Bob.
That part in Murder Scene was hilarious.

Really? Cool!

I feel so speshul. :shake:

Also, the eyelash thing was one of the inspirations for this story.

Whoa!!!!
That was very well written. X]
Me and my friends were reading it and kinda started screaming when we figured out it was Bob...O.o
But really cool, nice work! ^-^

:tehe:

I'm glad I managed to fool someone. No one saw the toilet paper thing? It's hilarious.

At first I thought it was Frank too, then I realised who it was at the part about the eyelash. I actually said out loud 'Oh my god, it's Bob!.'
I hope I didn't wake my dad up...
I remember pissing myself laughing at Mikey's reaction when I saw it. Then I was like really confused because I couldn't remember whether it was Bob or Frank that did it, but then I was like, Frank was sitting the other side of Gerard so it must have been Bob!

Anywho. I don't see anything wrong with this. It was wonderfully written. *applauds*

that was awesome! and i thought it was frankie =P