January 2nd, 2010 at 08:21am
Story Review Game
First of all, this bit of the summary hooked me: "What is love?
Love is a drug. It lifts you higher, and higher; and finally, you reach what is can only be described as levitation. The sweetest narcotic, the loveliest sin. And then? You learn to fall."
That part was amazing. I also love how you incorporated the story's title into the summary.
""What'd ya say? I was in the bathroom. I think the pipes froze again. No water comin' out." A masculine voice called, walking into the kitchen." There's a couple small errors in this sentence. There should be a comma after the bit of dialogue instead of a period, and the following "a" shouldn't be capitalized (I'm seeing a lot of this error in this chapter). Also, you should change the last part because a voice can't walk into a kitchen.
I found it hilarious how Mary repeatedly told David to take out the garbage.
Overall, this was an interesting story despite its grammatical errors. I really love how you use dialect in your dialogue, and I also love the dynamics of Mary and David's relationship. It's so real and honest instead of the fluff that I see in a lot of stories. I think this could turn into a really great story depending on how you decide to go with it.
I hope my review was helpful
I hope it's okay that I chose this story, even though it's not a one-shot. If not, then I can comment on another story if you like.
I like how normal this first chapter is, how the characters interact. The situation is everyday, yet the conclusion of the chapter tells a lot about their relationship. It's very sweet. I'm guessing there'll be more on her nephew in upcoming chapters, because he seems like he'll be an interesting character.
I have a bit of concrit:
Mary Hanley, 34 years of age, waltzed into the kitchen of their modest house only to spot the garbage can, its contents spilling out of the sides.
I thought that the '34 years of age' part sounded like something out of a news report. It could still work, but maybe you could try to incorporate it into the sentence in a different way?
And while I like the dialogue (I think it helps with characterisation), sometimes it felt a little forced. I do like the slang though.
The ending line was perfect. Overall, I thought it was a good start.