I love this story<3 It's so amazing! I love how you make the characters real and very... permanent. I liked the add in of Casey, who is totally horrible and makes John seem oddly nice. I hope you get your three comments so you can update today! :)
All in all I think that this is a creative story. The plot line is solid, it's decent and is being told from a good perspective. The idea is not totally original, but not overplayed either, which is a good thing, and works in your advantage. I did see a couple errors that were minor, a couple of missing places of punctuation, but details, details. I like this and you should definitely keep writing more! :)
I really really REALLY hate thatcher! I feel like he manipulates Harlow and purposely guilts her into being with him and if he was really a good friend, he'd understand that Harlow is with John and he should back off. John had every right to punch Thatcher because Thatch was egging him on and purposely getting under Johns skin. Harlow should most definetly pick John!
Well shit. I feel so bad for Thatcher, because he's in such a horrible position. I don't blame Harlow for not giving into Thatcher's words, Because she's also stuck in a horrible position. At least she gave Thatcher some sort of hope.
I am glad you updated because I've been thinking about this story a lot(: Thatcher and Harlow are just best friends for me so for whatever reason I am still on John's side, even if he's acting the way he is. I want them to work everything out, and be happily together. It's obvious that Harlow really likes John, and I think he likes her too. I can't wait for more. update soon?(: