Love Lost; Love Found - Comments

  • luminos.

    luminos. (600)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    28
    Location:
    United States
    Nick is so hot(:
    August 14th, 2010 at 11:48pm
  • turducken

    turducken (100)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    28
    Location:
    Canada
    Layout and Summary: Well, the layout really gives off the whole “teeny bob high school love story” feel, with the pink, purple and blue. You said it was slash, though it seems too girly for me. The summary is also quite vague, which is good in a sense but it doesn’t really do much to draw a reader in, this entire thing is based on a relationship however you don’t even hint at it in the summary. It’s just about someone getting into a car crash?

    Story:

    In the second paragraph I think you should change “flung” to rip or tore, mostly because you already used the verb flung in the first sentence, and then the word just becomes mundane after several uses.

    “Look, Mikayla, I’m sorry, but I don’t think I can go out with you anymore if you’re going to be this controlling,” He said.
    That would be a period not a comma.

    “Nick, I’m not being controlling, you’re just not listening to me, so I have to do stuff myself!” She said. Nick stared at her for a long time.
    I think you could go into more detail, how did she say it? How did he feel? So far all you’ve described are the sole actions of each person; however you never touch up on how they feel.

    “Mikayla, I don’t want to hurt you,” He said.
    Period not a comma.

    I know, Nick. I can see I’ve hurt you, though,” She said softly.
    That would be a period, and I think you should get rid of the “though”, mostly because that would imply in the next sentence she will add on to the fact, but she really doesn’t.

    “I’m sorry. I’ll go.” She turned to walk away.
    Again, describe her facial expressions. Describe how he felt seeing it. Was she ashamed? Was she pissing herself laughing? Was he angry, happy, did it hurt him?

    “Wait,” He said, getting out of the truck.
    He would be a lower case, if in the dialogue there is a comma than the following word is always a lower case.

    “At least let me give you a ride home.” She smiled softly.
    When you talk about her action afterward, it’s almost like she’s saying it. If you’re using dialogue, try to add what that person did afterwards, not what the person they were talking to did.

    “I can’t impose on you like that,” She said,
    It would be a period, not a comma.

    Also, in that paragraph, I find it a tad odd that she would let it go so easily. When someone’s controlling they absolutely despise when things are in their hands, mainly out of their control. She would most likely have a freak or turn the situation into her hands, most likely dumping him. Again, how does he feel?

    The dude just broke up with his girlfriend; you can easily elaborate on the feelings that are passing through his mind. The reader doesn’t know much about him, about their relationship, and for all we know he could be stunned with happiness, or maybe he’s suicidal? We don’t know what’s going on through your mind; we don’t know how anyone looks, what the setting looks like, or how they feel. You must explain this.

    Grissom would never forgive him.
    Was Grissom his boss? Explain why Grissom would never forgive him, is he a punctual, controlling man? Describe like we’ve never heard of his character before.

    There was a squeal of tires on asphalt,
    I think you should include something like “suddenly” or “abruptly” to show that this happened to him. For a moment I was confused about what was happening, and I think that would increase a better flow.

    In the next paragraph elaborate how he’s feeling. Dizzy, okay. But he almost died; I think that’s going to bring up a lot. Memories? Thrashing heartbeats? Maybe he blacked out?

    “Mr. Stokes! Are you all right?” He asked,
    How did he ask? Was he concerned? Was he laughing? Whispering? Imposing?

    “You were driving through the light and a drunk driver flew through the red light and slammed into your car,”
    Period not a comma.

    He tried to smile but found it hard to at this time.
    Why did he find it hard? Was it the after shock? Did it hurt?

    “In the other ambulance. He’s not in very good shape,”
    Period.

    “Well, hopefully he’ll be all right,”
    Period.

    “I have to get back to the station and let everyone know you’re all right,”
    Period.

    He half hoped Greg would stop by,
    What’s this guy’s relationship with him?

    He thought.
    He wondered?

    “You’re awake,” He said simply,
    Period.

    “Yeah, I slept right through the night,”
    Period.

    “I know,” He said softly.
    Lower case on the he.

    The doctor walked into the room.
    How did she walk into the room? Were her footsteps loud, so they heard before she stepped in, or were they so soft that it was like a sneak attack?

    “Mr. Stokes, I’m Dr. Lowry,”
    Period.

    Nick nodded.
    Again, add something she did before explaining his actions.

    He said.
    He asked.

    “At least two weeks,”
    Period, and you can go into how he felt about no work.

    “I’ll give you two and a half,” Grissom said.
    Period, and how’d he say it? With a smile? Regretfully?
    And you should stray away from the word nodded; you used it a lot in only a few sentences. Try a different word, because like I said then it becomes mundane.

    “That sounds like a reasonable amount of time,”
    Period.

    “I’ll give you a ride home,”
    Period.

    Overall, the plot isn’t that bad. It’s only the beginning so you have a lot to work with. I think that you should’ve kept the girlfriend, at least for a while because that could be an obstacle they overcame together, but they could still sneak around.

    You’ve got a “he said, she said, he did, she did” type of thing going. You shouldn’t just describe the actions, however describe what they’re feeling. What’s the setting like? What does it smell like? Are they happy, sad, how do they do things? It helps with building a character.

    And also, if you have a sentence in dialogue, if without the quotations it’s a sentence, than you put a period at the end. Only if its things like “You know,” she spoke quietly, “we’ve got a lot of things to do today.” You know isn’t a sentence by itself, however with the following quotations it becomes one.

    Hope that helped.
    July 9th, 2010 at 08:43pm
  • Undefined;;

    Undefined;; (150)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    29
    Location:
    United States
    This was so cute! I've never seen a CSI fanfiction, let alon slash! I loved it!
    July 6th, 2010 at 10:12pm
  • ghostbrainz.

    ghostbrainz. (100)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    28
    Location:
    United States
    I thought that was extremely adorable.
    Especially how Grissom just sort of kissed him and ran. (:
    Anyways, great job and good luck!
    June 25th, 2010 at 02:40am
  • strigoi.

    strigoi. (395)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    31
    Location:
    United States
    Contest judging;:

    Okay, so I thought this was pretty good. The only thing I found to be weird was that when he crashed, you said the cop helped him to an ambulance, mere seconds after the crash. I don't understand how an ambulance was there only seconds after the crash. It doesn't make much sense.

    Other than that, I thought it was quite good. I enjoy all the CSI shows, so that helped with the details too. Thanks for entering this in my contest! I'll let you know when I'm done with the judging process && winners are announced!!!<3
    June 3rd, 2010 at 05:48pm
  • schmickles.

    schmickles. (100)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    30
    Location:
    United States
    I'm not the biggest fan of slash, but I do like CSI. I like the way you put this together. Very nicely done!
    June 1st, 2010 at 07:55pm
  • fawndling

    fawndling (100)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    24
    Location:
    United States
    "Nick got into his truck from his house, slamming the door shut." This sentence could be written more clearly. It sounds as if he climbed out a window or something in his house and straight into the car. You could try something like "Nick strode purposefully from his house towards his car, hopping in and slamming the door shut."

    " The officer caught him and helped him to the nearest ambulance." It's hard to grasp why there would be an ambulance around seconds after a crash. It sounds like he's at a police station, but there wouldn't be ambulances there. The crash scene needs a little bit more description.

    "He couldn’t sleep, and he didn’t dare turn on the television, so he occupied himself with staring at ceilings" It would more likely be "...staring at the ceiling." so that it doesn't sound as if there are multiple ceilings in one room.

    I really liked this story. Without ever having watched the show, I can still get a firm grasp on what's going on. The romance was very subtle, which was nice, and the plot was, for the most part, very easy to follow. Thanks for entering this in my contest :)
    June 1st, 2010 at 07:32pm
  • restingplatypus

    restingplatypus (100)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    33
    Location:
    United States
    I'm not really big on CSI, anymore. I used to really digg it. lol. But, I like the pairing. It's not an expected pairing, which made it even better! & I'm not big on third person, either. But, you made it flow very well! I like it.:)
    May 27th, 2010 at 07:43am
  • slowburnbaby

    slowburnbaby (100)

    :
    Member
    Gender:
    Age:
    30
    Location:
    United States
    Normally Im not a huge fan of slash, but there are a few stories I get into, and I love your style of slash, its not the WHAM BAM in your face, but its nioce and simple and sweet, I love stories like that, Great job dear!
    May 17th, 2010 at 03:48am