Just his constant disbelief at the fact he was /fucking a bagel/ had me in tears. "He was fucking a bagel. And the bagel would never tell a soul." Bravo, this is one of the most intelligently hilarious things I've ever read.
i haven't read anything quite this ridiculous since i read a story featuring alex gaskarth and a fetish for dressing up his penis, particularly with a top hat. bravo.
Oh my gosh. This is just... too good for words. I never, ever would have thought I'd read anything like this, but I when I saw it I just had to give it a try and it was so worth it. I love the tone of the whole thing, it's so amusing how he's debating the entire thing. And the whole cream cheese thing at the end was a perfect finish. It's definitely one of my favourite reads, seriously brightened my day :)
God, I'm not sure if I can say anything different than anyone else. This seriously killed me, I was laughing and rolling on the ground. Just those little one-liners. :D Cream cheese...bahahahahaha.
I saw your link to this in the 'highest rated stories' thread with 'Ryan fucking a bagel' and decided that I had to read it.
I usually stick to MCR fiction because I'm closed minded like that (or most of the stories I read lately, people suggest to me: either or), but this was hilarious. I've never actually thought of reading Panic fanfics, the closest I've read was a crossover in which they were featured. Needless to say, after reading this, I'm probably going to go through a phase of flooding my browser with Panic fiction, so thanks for that. Hah.
I really liked this though, if you didn't already get that. You ended it on an absolutely perfect note. "I threw your bagel away. I took a bite, but I guess our cream cheese is bad or something." I'm laughing so hard right now.