March 10th, 2014 at 04:39am
Reply from Comment Swap:
I'm not sure which story I was supposed to read for comment swap, but I thought this one was most interesting from the titles. :)
This is really well written! I love how Karina's POV is not just narration or what she sees, it's what is in her head, and I love how she is talking to her mom and the Sillyboots in her head as well, it leads us into her mind without being hassled by all the details of her surroundings.
I saw how you capitalized things that are deemed important to children from the way they are taught to view those things :D Money, Important Enough, These Days... these days ideas and concepts in children's minds that hold some sort of meaning, and you showed that so clearly and fluently. Children also have run-on sentences that lead from one point to another, which you showed. Two thumbs up!
One part that I didn't really see clearly was what was happening to Karina... that was left all to the imagination, and it could have been anything. Is she supposed to die in the end? That's what I felt from the way it ended and what led up to it. If that wasn't your intention then for scenes like these you would need a little more description of the scene (but maybe that's just me, lol)
Overall I loved it, and I will definitely recommend this :) Amazing work, you're really talented!!
Hey there, thank you so much for the comment. I really took a dive into the unknown with this story and the type of narration you used. I'm happy you understood why I capitalized those words specifically.
I understand how this story can be vague and misleading, and considering how old this story is (almost 2 years old) I've decided to explain what was really happening (hopefully this won't ruin its magic).
This story was set in 1940's Nazi occupied Poland, when the anti-Semitic demonstrations by the German army were starting to be more violent. Karina's mother forgot to bring her documents with them, and were accused of being 'juden' (jews). You are right: Karina did get shot and died. Her mother? I won't ruin that much.
Again thank you for the comment, I truly appreciate it.