I loved this! James Neal is one of my favorite players and Nothing is one of my favorite songs- you got a pretty good combo that I had high expectations for! And rightly so, because you did a very good job. I liked that James seemed to be really head over heels in love with Samanthat and that she was the one who back out. I liked that you stayed true to the song, instead of twisting it all around. I'm glad you included his teammates, as it wouldn't be a hockey story without 'em.
I have a few other extensions out right now, so I hope to have the results up by Monday!