March 3rd, 2013 at 04:49am
Hello to you! The Comment Swap thingy brought me here and now I've read this story, so here's my review:
This is far from the stories I normally read and since there is only one chapter I can't really make out that much from it, however I like the way you write. Especially the way you wrote the dialogues. It was casual, but had some fun things in as well and sarcasm- at least the way I read it. I love when it's like that in stories, it makes them seem so much more realistic and not as..."robotic" as others might be. So that's a huge plus with me! :) I wish you would have more chapters out and posted because it was quite entertaining to read and I wanted to see where this story is going. :)
The only thing I have to say is that I would personally loved a description. Or at least what it might be about, even if I did love the quote because it could go really well with the story. The only reason for the description, it would have shown what fan-dom this belonged it heheh :)
Otherwise, really good for the first chapter!
Don't get me wrong with this comment but, this story should have either been longer or had more of a filling. It just seems a little empty and ugh, there's just something missing.
I get that Jack's lecturing the Doctor about his feelings over Rose but, you could have just added so much more to this piece. The ending broke my heart though; are they or aren't they gonna get it on? I wanna know!
Maybe you should think about going back and changing it around; maybe a two shot or something? Great piece though; I'm having so many feels over it right now.