It's a Giving Game - Comments

@ kickthepj
I DO LOVE IT U FOOL it's so good but it absolutely ruined my life and I've never been the same. But if you really wanna delete it I can always save a copy just for me and that'll let u get rid of it if u wanted? JUST AN IDEA but it is genuinely good and I love it.

@ joelkanitz
I LITERALLY CANNOT BELIEVE U AKJHAJFH. every time i think about this fic i just remember how much i HATE IT now and wanna delete it, but i also remember that you always claim to love it so i keep it up just for u :')

It is the year 2020 and I just want you to know I re-read this fic and it still reduced me to tears.

@ gh0stfully
nO DONT CRY WTF let me hug you and yes the blurb description made sense ur cute thanks a bunch <3 let's just pretend it was all a dream alex is actually alive forever and they live happily together 6ever the end :o)

i used to have a fanfic like little blurb thing (you know like how on the iPhone you can group apps well i did it with fics ok does that make sense) on my phone and this one was in it

this fic fucked me up so badly but in a good way like it's so beautiful and i love it i love it so much i cannot read it without crying this is one of my favorites in the whole world this is WONDERFUL i cannot describe how much i LOVE THIS okay

i used to have a fanfic like little blurb thing (you know like how on the iPhone you can group apps well i did it with fics ok does that make sense) on my phone and this one was in it

this fic fucked me up so badly but in a good way like it's so beautiful and i love it i love it so much i cannot read it without crying this is one of my favorites in the whole world this is WONDERFUL i cannot describe how much i LOVE THIS okay

@ kickthepj
i want to sleep forever but i have to go to work and it's early and no

@ kickthepj
i want to sleep forever but i have to go to work and it's early and no

@ brxndneweyes

eve no bb ily don't be sad!!! sometimes sad is good ok, bc when you're sad over fics you can always remind yourself that it's not even real and there are a million trillion real life reasons to smile and be happy!!!!!! and remember that the fic is sort of happy too, bc alex died happy and lovey all around:)))))) don't be sad ily ok you're rlly cute and thinking of cuties being sad makes me sad. just think of nice things, think of how soft jack's hair must be oh boy what a thought. if you can't help your feelings just drink some chocolate milk and listen to patd's first album bc it's so wonderful and then read fics that aren't mine and aren't sad and yayyyyy:)))) ily!!!!!!

i was really sad and it's 3am an d i should be sleeping i have wor k tomorrow but i was sasd so i started reading sad fics and i decided to read this one again and i do knt know why because im literally hysterical now im so sadd

I am fairly certain that it is illegal for something to be this well written and one of the one shot and short stories ever written. Seriously. This is only one of VERY few stories that nearly made me cry. Oh my god. Freaking amazing.

I am fairly certain that it is illegal for something to be this well written and one of the one shot and short stories ever written. Seriously. This is only one of VERY few stories that nearly made me cry. Oh my god. Freaking amazing.

well this was a thousand shades of Not Okay. but i loved it. it's so well written and beautiful and amazing

I cried like a baby. This fic makes me really redicukously happy, it's so well written, and such a beautiful little love story, but it ends up stabbing you in the feels repetitively. 6103642902/10 would recommend to anyone.

@ brxndneweyes

i feel sorry for making you sad pls feel free to imagine me hugging you as we cry together to make it better

i recommended this to someone on atff and i skimmed the end again and i only read like two paragraphs and my throat has such a terrible lump in it from trying not to cry its like i swallowed a fucking bowling ball and i wanna die oh my g o d i just want baby jack to be happy with his life because alex loved him and loved how much he tried and this hurts so much

This is so amazing it made my stomach feel weird in a good way the whole way through but god do I hate you for the ending because fuck man it could have ended happy

i might throw up oh my god i have never cried so mucj over a fic before in my
whole life i cant even see im wheezing
youre a beautiful person holy shit

this made my stomach twist and squeeze the whole way through in a really strange way because jack was trying so hard to give alex everything and alex loved it all anyway and it was just really beautiful and it hurts

i'm doing that really ugly sob-cry-blow-nose thing

IM TRYING NOT TO CRY BUT ITS NOT WORKING