All We Will Never Know

It is the first day of senior year for the students of Everwood Academy, but it is also the day that Will Armstrong returns from jail. Two years have passed since Bella Armstrong was found strangled and drowned in her family pond, while her brother was nearly convicted of the crime. But it's impossible for anyone to forget what happened. Even after he was found not guilty of murder, and put in jail for a completely separate crime, the community can't help but label him as a monster.

Especially when, on the night of his return home, another teenage girl disappears.

Told in the POV of five main characters.