Love Isn't Always Fair

I woke up the next morning in Andy's bed. He was still asleep next to me so I reached for my phone on his nightstand, seeing that I had 12 missed calls. From who? Why would someone call me that much...

Unlocking my phone, I had seen that all calls wee from Ricky. I couldn't help but wonder what had happened. So, I decided to call him back.

He answered on the third ring. "Chris?"

"Yeah, what's up Rick?" I asked.

He sighed. "I would've called Andy but I didn't have his number, how did you not hear your phone going off?"

"Dude I was sleeping," I admitted.

"Well that's not important," he said. "Ashley came over last night, balling his fucking eyes out because he said there's nothing good left in his life. And me being the nice guy, I was like cuddling with him and shit. He was telling me how much he wants Andy back? I don't know man."

I heavily sighed. What am I going to do? I want to stay with Andy more than anything, but Ashley is in love with him. But I love Andy, he's my boyfriend. Fuck. "Are you still with him?"

"Yeah, he slept over last night. I'm outside right now," he spoke.

I groaned. "Fuck. What should I do?"

"I think they need to talk it out," he suggested. "Bring him over here."

"Alright, see you in a few," I said before hanging up.

Fuck. I love Andy, Andy loves me, Ashley loves Andy. It's like a big fucking love triangle. Fuck love triangles. Why couldn't the three of us just date? Everything would be so much fucking easier and no one would end up getting hurt.

I looked over at Andy who looked so peaceful. But I had to wake him up. I put my hands on his shoulders, lightly shaking him awake. About a couple seconds later, his crystal blue eyes squinted with his nose scrunched up.

"It's Saturday, why are you waking me up," he groaned.

I sighed, brushing the hair out if his face. "We have to go to Ricky's."

"For what?" he asked, sitting up.

I got out of his bed to put some clothes on. Grabbing a random shirt and pants from my bag, I looked back at him. "Ashley."

"W-what happened?" he stuttered.

Changing into my clothes for the day, I walked into the bathroom. I started drawing my eyebrows on when Andy walked in the bathroom, still naked from sleeping. He rubbed his tired eyes before taking a pee.

After we were done with everything, we got into my car and took off to Ricky's. I still haven't told Andy what happened but I figured it would be best if Ashley talked to him about it. I was really contemplating this whole three way relationship though, I mean I would mind dating Ashley too. He's gorgeous and he has an amazing personality. And then there's my best friend, Andy.

When I pulled into Ricky's driveway, he was sitting outside with a cigarette in his hand. We both got out of my car to go talk to Ashley. Ricky lead us inside and into his room to find Ashley curled up on his bed.

"Did Chris tell you what happened?" Ricky asked Andy.

He shook his head. "No, he just said something happened to him." Andy walked over to Ashley and leaned down close to his face. He poked his nose which made me smile, he's so fucking cute.

"What," Ashley groaned.

"What happened?" Andy asked.

Ricky left the room to leave us to talk. Ashley sprung up from the bed, facing Andy. "Andy, I'm still in love with you." He had then faced me. "I'm sorry Chris."

"Don't be," I smiled. They both looked at me confused before I walked over to the both of them. "I've been thinking, and it's totally up to you guys. What if we do like a three way relationship?"

They both looked at each other, then looked back at me. They both shrugged and slightly smiled.

"I could do that," Ashley smiled.

"Yeah," Andy agreed.

I grabbed both of their hands with mine and smiled at them. "This could be a lot of fun."

"Threesomes," Andy smirked.

I rolled my eyes and chuckled. "I fucked you three times yesterday, you fucking sleaze."

"Hey!" he yelled in defense. After a few seconds, he leaned in closer to me and pressed his lips to mine. When he pulled away I figured Ashley was feeling a little left out. I grabbed his hair with my hands, pulling him to me and placed my lips on his. Ashley's hands went straight to my hips.

Andy gasped. "Fuck, that's hot."

"Yeah?" I smirked as I pulled away from Ashley.

"Can one of you please suck me off?" Ashley groaned.

Andy and I looked at each other, unsure of who wanted to do it. I wouldn't mind doing it at all. I think it would be fun, actually. Plus I have no gag reflex which is perfect.

"I don't have a gag reflex," I quietly said, smirking.

Ashley cocked an eyebrow. "Then get on your knees."

I really couldn't believe we were doing this in Ricky's room. Oh well, he'll get over it. I got down on my knees in front of Ashley before pulling his shorts down, his erection bulging out of his boxers. I slid my hand in the slit of them and ran my hand along his member, finding out that he was pretty big, but not as big as me.

He lightly moaned. "Fuck."

Andy groaned, pushing me away from Ashley. "Get out of my way."

Taken a bit back, I watched as Andy pulled Ashley's boxers down, taking him into his mouth. And my god that was fucking hot. His head started moving up and down when I realized I had enough. I unbuttoned and unzipped Andy's pants while he was kneeling on the floor before pulling them off him, carelessly throwing them. I tangled my hands in his hair, pushing Ashley deeper down his throat. Andy gagged so I released my hands from his head. I pushed two fingers by Ashley's mouth, he looked at me confused first before he placed them into his mouth. I lightly moaned when I felt him swirl his tongue around them. Pulling my fingers out of his mouth, I placed them near Andy's entrance.

I pushed a finger into him, hearing a muffled moan. I wiggled it around in him before I pushed another finger into his tight hole. He grabbed his leaking cock, pumping himself while he deep throated Ashley.

"Fuck, I'm almost there," Ashley moaned.

I shoved my fingers further into him, causing him to take Ashley out of his mouth and scream from pleasure. I had definitely hit his prostate. He looked back at me with those innocent eyes.

"Chris," he breathed out.

I smirked before Ashley started jerking himself off. Andy got the cue to give him his attention, he put Ashley back into his mouth. I repetitively hit Andy's spot which made him constantly moan. Ashley moaned loudly, indicating that he finished off in Andy's mouth. Andy swallowed his load as I took my fingers out of him.

Ashley got up from the bed to put his pants back on. "I can't wait for a threesome."

Andy got up from the floor, still half naked and walked over to Ashley. He smiled before he placed his lips on his. I couldn't help but feel jealous... I wasn't sure if this was going to work.