Update on Summit's New Moon - Comments

Dakota Fanning doesn't fit the character in the book. In the book Bella first thought Jane was a boy until she got closer. Jane was supposed to have short hair.

I don't want VH to play Leah. I don't want a single disney star in the movie. That would ruin it in my opinion.

I don't really think that Dakota Fanning would be so good for the part, but I guess I can't do anything about it. It just seems that a lot of her movies, she's usually a nice girl. In [i]New Moon[/i] Jane appears at first and ice cold bitch.

If Dakota Fanning can pull that off, then I'm glad if she gets the part.

i think the fanning kid would be a good Jane.
but no to hudgens. she can die in the film shooting for all i care.

um... what the hell.. okay i had a total fanmeltdown when i heard about decota.. i mean. she is a good actress but she is not vindictive. and i cant see her as a complet bitch. like jane.. and i would so not see equlips if huggens made it.. hello even thought it is my fav. one in the sears. she isint native american... she is hispanic.!! and it just wouldnt make sence.. and better yet if that hore is going to make it seth better be some one worth wild. or i will be pissed!!!

I love Dakota Fanning but Vanessa Hudgens can't act for shit.

"I know that Twilight is so sacred to some people..."
That made me crack up.

And I think Hudgens should be in it; the fan base is ignorant enough of good acting to welcome her with open arms.

=]

I'm wasn't even going to watch any of the other movies, and now Vanessa trying to act in a REAL movie? Screw that noise she's a god damn SLUT.

It makes no difference to me =]
Vanessa Hudgens can be in it all she wants to for all I care.

I honestly see Dakota playing Jane. She always stars in dark mysterious movies anyway. So I know she'll do a good job. As for Vanessa,I did hear she was to be in New Moon and the first character that popped in my mind was Leah. If she is going to play Leah, I hope she does a good Job.

NOOOOOO. She's going to kill it. Next thing you know, they're going to want to be casting Miley Cyrus. Gahhhh.

I would be very disipointed if Jane was played by Dakota Fanning.
Shes to whiney and I dont know if she could ever capture the whole Jane tone and feel. Also if Venessa would play Leah I dont think I could have any respect for the whole Twilight Saga becomes a movie thing. Im sorry but every character that was in the movie a perfect role, Venessa and Dekota I think would ruin the movie. =\

I don't see a problem with Vanessa Hudgens. I mean, if they're willing to let Robert go on with his life after his "partying", why not let Vanessa have a part in her life too? I'd like to see her in a role outside of High School Musical, and Disney for sure. Either way, Leah is going to be snobbish and bitter, but pretty.

I do like the idea of Dakota Fanning as Jane. She has a total creep factor, and I could totally see her as a bloodsucking child. I would not mind that a bit. I do know I won't be crying though, not during this movie.

VANESSA SHOULD STAY OUT!
I love Dakota, she'll be a GREAT Jane.
Can't wait to see it!

I think Vanessa nor Dakota should be in this film. Vanessa cause I don't think she could be Leah at all and Dakota is to big. I loved twilight because of all the unknown actors. Dakota is just one of those actors that everyone knows about.
it just ruins everything

Ew, I do not like Vanessa Hudgens at all. She is NOT a good choice.

Rumor has it that Tom Felton's up for the part of Alec, though. ^-^ That makes me happy.

tbh, twilight became a hell of a lot worse than HSM as soon as the film was released
(:
So vanessa would be a perfect fit in my honest opinion.

I think vanessa is too girly/disney for it.

Why would fans have a problem with Vanessa?
:shifty

The only thing I can think of is her success overshadowing the film.

wow i think that this movie is going to suck just like the book and the other movie.

actually I read in an article somewhere it actually WAS just a rumor and that the character Leah Clearwater will be played by a Native American