I don't think any comment could ever be too long. =P
The longest I ever wrote was somewhere around the 1,500 mark, but that was after I was dared to write a longer comment than the one I'd written before that - which was somewhere around 800 words. If you really love a story, sometimes it just can't be helped.
omg the fact that you wrote a long comment on my baby story ( I READ IT ALL OH MY GOD I LOVE YOU KATIE ) but made a blog for it too i'm so glad that you love it. i am secretly in love with you but you can't know that bc it's a secret so shh i said nothing but UGH I LOVE YOU & THANK YOU IM SO FLATTERED.
That's awesome! That's like a dream comment, like orange county. said. It's awesome to see readers that are passionate enough to write super long comments.
I don't think a comment can ever be too long, personally. To have someone engage with the story so much that they just can't stop talking about it, isn't that what every writer wants?
Go you for being able to write such a long comment, I always struggle to make mine worthwhile.
The longest I ever wrote was somewhere around the 1,500 mark, but that was after I was dared to write a longer comment than the one I'd written before that - which was somewhere around 800 words. If you really love a story, sometimes it just can't be helped.