I Have Never... || Make-Up People, Read the Last Paragraph. - Comments

Not sure if you're big on CF/vegan makeup so I'll just suggest the non-CF options.

Clinique has an All About Eyes eye cream that you can buy a small jar of to try out or ask for a sample at the counter.

Color correct the darkness with a peach/salmon corrector (Bobbi Brown has one, for example) before you apply concealer. LA Girl Cosmetics added lighter shades of concealer to their expansive range so it might work for you. (My fave concealer haha.)

If not, Maybelline Face Studio Master Conceal in fair or light; Rimmel concealer (lasting perfection or fit me; fit me concealer has microshimmer particles to brighten up the eye area).

Hope that helps. ULTA has BOGO 50% on Maybelline and Rimmel almost all the time so you won't be spending too much if you don't end up loving it and want to opt for the higher end options suggested below. Good luck.

You should check out BB/CC creams! They're good for your skin and act as a foundation. I actually use this serum thing (BB cream but called something fancier) from Bare Minerals called Pure Brightening Serum Foundation, and I use it as both a foundation and concealer. It works pretty well, even on my eye bags

For concealer, Nars Radiant Creamy concealer is good and so is Urban Decay Naked Skin concealer

Idk about plumping them, but I heard the it Cosmetics "Bye Bye Undereye" concealer is a holy grail. It's on the thick side, which would be good.