Nothing is What it Seems | Closed.

Matt raised his brows. "Uh," he mumbled, tapping his fingers on the steering wheel. His brows furrowed as he thought. "I'm not exactly sure." He hadn't thought about that before. It was going to be awkward enough as is, but with his wife in the mix as well? He just couldn't imagine that. If this was a totally different situation and they had a few drinks in them and he wasn't trying to impregnate this other girl, then maybe.

"If she wants to be involved I wouldn't mind," Andi admitted. "My first time that actually involved vaginal penetration was a threesome." She chewed on her bottom lip as she thought back on the experience. "My first time ever having sex was with a girl so I guess what I'm saying is maybe it'll be easier on us both if she's there. Since she's your wife and I tend to be morw comfortable around women than men."

Matt was totally and utterly confused. If she was more comfortable with girls then why was she wanting to be a surrogate mother and offering to do it the old-fashioned way? He was totally clueless. He pulled into the driveway of his home and got out of the car, leading her inside. He'd leave it up to his wife. But he wasn't so sure he was comfortable with a threesome. This wasn't what this was about.

"When you're a surrogate you get to chose the couple you want, " Andi mumbled. "You're apart of one of my favorite bands and your wife makes me feel safe. I had a bad past with men thanks to my step-dad. So it just takes longer for me to warm up to men." Andi shoved her hands in her jean pockets as she climbed out of the car, feeling like she had just made everything weird. "Please tell me I'm not making this weird," she mumbled. "I have this really bad problem where I don't know when to just keep quiet."

Matt smiled and turned to face her. "No, everything's fine," he said. "I've had fans come up to me and tell me worse things than their past sexual experiences." He reached out and gently patted her shoulder before leading her into the living room where Ellie was. He walked over and pulled her up, pressing his lips to hers. "Drive home okay?"

Ellie grinned and nodded. "How was your ride home," she asked. "Find out anything new about the mother to be?" The blonde wasn't going to openly admit it but she found the brunette adorable. If her eyes were hazel and her jaw line was more rounded she could see Andi as the female version of Matt.

"Matt told me you guys decided on me having the baby the old fashioned way," Andi spoke up. "I'm kinda of nervous about since it'll my seventh time having sex and only my second time with a guy." Ellie's eyes widened when Andi mention how few times she'd had sex. "You poor thing," she exclaimed. "Sex is amazing with the right person. Like for me sex with Matt is like floating on clouds while eating a shit ton of my favorite candy and staying thin while doing it."

Matt looked at Ellie and laughed softly. He found it weird that they just openly talked about their sex lives with each other, but he guessed that's what girls did. He looked at Ellie and smiled. "She suggested you join us," he said. "But it's between you two." He glanced over at Andi. "I wouldn't hurt you, I hope you know that. And if you wanted me to stop, I would. I understand if you change your mind."

Ellie looked at Andi and bit down on hee bottom lip, thinking of the how having a threesome could play out. She wasn't sure that's what she wanted until maybe after they were sure the brunette was pregnant. Or maybe they'd wait after the baby. "How about this," she suggested. "How about all three of us go up to Matt and my room and you two start on the baby. I won't get involved but I'll be in the room as moral support."

Andi looked between Ellie and Matt, chewing on her bottom lip before she nodded at Ellie's suggestion. "I can't stay the night though. I have work in the morning which means i'll need a ride back to my car."

Matt nodded his head. "I'll give you a ride back," he said. He tuned to Ellie and kissed her lips gently. "Are you sure you're okay with this?" he asked quietly, reaching up and pushing a strand of hair behind her ear. He knew how she could get jealous from time to time, so this was kind of weird to him that she was so eager for him to sleep with another woman.

Ellie nodded. "I trust her Matt," she replied. "She's here to give us the baby we've always wanted not steal you away from me like those groupie skanks try to." She pecked his lips, taking his hand in on of hers and then grabbed Andi's hand in her other one, leading them both upstairs to the bedroom. She sat down on the chair she had near her make up stand, letting both Matt and Andi's hand go.

Andi slid off her shoes, sliding off her socks and then pulled off her t-shirt. She nervously crossed her arms over her chest, feeling self conscious as the couple watched her get naked.

Matt cleared his throat and looked away from Andi, taking his shoes and socks off, tossing them aside before he started taking his clothes off as well. First went his shirt, then his belt, then his pants, and then his boxers, until he was totally naked in front of this girl, that was supposed to be the mother of his and Ellie's baby.

Andi blushed and she slid out of the rest of her clothes, staring at Matt and blushing when she looked at his length. "You really are hung like a horse, " she mumbled. Ellie nudged Andi to get closer to Matt and make a move so she did. She lead Matt to bed, sitting down on it and presses her lips against his.

Matt stood there awkwardly for a moment before he kissed her back, gently pushing her back a bit on the bed and climbing on top of her. He pulled back and looked over her body before he leaned down and kissed her neck. He ran his hands over her sides, down to her hips, giving them a gentle squeeze.

Ellie watched Matt and Andi, noticing how awkward they see me together. "Matt if you don't want to do this just say so," she spoke. When Andi looked at her the blonde flashed her a reassuring smile, giving the brunette the small confidence boost she needed. Andi reached in between her and Matt, slowly stroking his length as she leaned forward to kiss his lips again.

Matt let out a soft moan, kissing her back. He tried to act as if Ellie wasn't sitting there watching them, reaching between Andi's legs and touching her. He ran his fingers over her slit, finding her clit and rubbing it slowly. He was actually kind of starting to get pretty excited and turned on. It would be different to have sex with another woman other than his wife, but not only that, she was approving of it. And this woman was also going to give him a baby to start the family he'd dreamed of having.

Andi moaned against Matt's lips, feeling herself getting wet between her legs. She was so turned on between the feeling of Ellie's eyes on her and Matt's hand in between her legs. She began grinding her hips against his hand, moaning louder as she got more stimulation to her clit from it.

Matt pressed his face into her neck, sucking lightly on her skin as he rubbed her clit. He moved his fingers over her slit, gently pressing two into her. He pumped his fingers into her gently, letting out a soft moan against her neck.

Andi moaned out Matt's name, grinding her body against Matt's wanting more than just his fingers. She wanted to feel him stretch her insides and fill her completely.

Matt pulled his fingers from her and lined up at her entrance, slowly pushing into her. He moaned softly, pressing his lips to hers. She felt so amazing, and he could tell she really didn't have much sex, unlike he and Ellie did.

Andi let out a shallow gasp, followed by a loud breathy moan, her eyes meeting Ellie's and she moved to cup her breasts. She returned Matt's kiss when he pressed his lips hers, moving to wrap her arms around his neck.

Ellie was unbelievably turned on as she watched Andi and Matt have sex. Her hands found their way into her underwear, one hand toying with her nipples while the other rubbing her clit.