I think you should three way with him.
That's what me and my friends do with my guy. It's because I'm a really shy person and I've never actually talked to him. We talk on AIM and most definitely know who each other is. He's also too shy to talk to me.
True, true. But I'm very picky. When I like someone, I like one one else but them. If someone asks me to be their girlfriend, I'll say no unless it's that someone I like.
It's the complete opposite of my friends. They have boyfriends just because they can. They have new ones every week.
I've got a guy who I think is super hot, and he's the only guy who's actually called me cute ever. I really like him, but hate him at the same time. the first month I knew him, every day would end up in him calling me cute. Now that he's seen my friends, he wants me to ask them to be his girlfriends. They said no.
Of course!
xD