Maddie should say yes. That's what Maddie should do, and anything otherwise should result in a heavy assault to the face. :D Don't ask where that came from... Anyway, lovely chapter! I do like how jerkish John is being and becoming, I understand where he is with the pain from Maddie leaving, but its nearly obvious that he's forced himself to get over her. As for Kennedy, I like him with Maddie but Garrett is... it's Garrett, he deserves to win in life! :D
I love this story, as you already know. I am team Garrett. I am super excited for the next chapter. Maybe they can make out and have sexytime because he deserves it more than either boy. Am I the only one?! Haha. This next chapter is going to be the best, I can sense it.
“You should have hit him back, Kenny! I totally had my money on you,” Pat said. That made me giggle. I love Pat.
John is a dumb boy. He has Maddie wrapped around his finger and breaks her heart. Now he's jealous? If he had her then why would he hurt her? So stupid. Kennedy is a sweetheart, but the drama with having Maddie's niece as his daughter? WAY too much drama. This is why I am team Garrett. Even though I was disappointed that he wasn't a good date and tried to hook up with someone else. They should've had their New Years kiss together, but that part where Kennedy and Maddie were outside was beautifully written. “You could break any girls heart with a smile like that, Kennedy.” “Even yours?” he asked. “Especially mine,” she said quietly as they started intently into each other’s eyes. Sexytime... and then, not. What a disappointment. I like it better this way though. So dramatastic.
“I’ll just call you when I’m in need of some loving, Gare,” Maddie said. “Why? Because you think I’m sexy?” Garrett wiggled his eyebrows. Maddie laughed, “And convenient,” she said, taking a bite of ice cream. Garrett rolled his eyes, “You just keep telling yourself that you don’t want me, I know the truth.” Ooh! I want this to happen. I think he's the best choice for Maddie, and if not, I'll take him. I'd take some Garrett loving anytime, any place.