This is my first time reading this, but I've got to say that I most definitely prefer the alternate ending...although a small part of that has to do with Joe and Demi getting married...
Wow. This story has AMAZED me. It is most definitely different from the many stories that I have read and very, very fantastic. The alternate endings made it really cool cause even though I usually root for Nick, I was stuck between the two but wanted something else for once. And you did that(: You're a very talented writer and - this is for your other stories- even if you don't get many comments or subscribers or something, don't EVER doubt yourself. Just write because you want to, and don't feel like you NEED those comments, just be grateful every time you get one. I understand they sometimes give inspiration but not all of it comes from that, it also comes from yourself, and things around you. How simple things can make a billion pictures pop into you're head. You'd be surprised. Although I think you've gotten a few of those already. Well anyways enough with my rambling and going "deep", I really enjoyed your story and will be reading the rest and looking out for new ones(:
I WILL COMMENT ONE MORE TIME THANK YOU VERY MUCH! haha Anyway, loved both endings even though they both made me quite sad...but that means you're able to make me feel Sam's pain so that's good!...or that my depression is acting up again...in which case that's bad...eh, either way I loved the endings :) haha And yes, its still Mollie, I just changed my username...