But You Loved Me - Comments

Please don't break my heart. Please finish this lovely story!!

Oh my god how fucking sad. Poor Frankie. He actually does remember he needed to remember something important but he can't remember how sad. He knows he needs to remember it but like he can't. It's so hard to explain what I'm thinking right now. And Gee isn't lying when he said frank doesnt remember him becuz he actually does. Frank just can't recall it. My gosh I wanna cry now great story!!

WHATTTTT???!!! I mean...WHATTHEFUCK??!! Gerard....frank...WHAT. IS GOING. ON. NO. NO THIS IS NOT OKAY. HE CAN'T JUST NOT REMEMBER HIM. NO. IT'S NOT FAIR NO.
I need an update please!!
-V ;)

.... Hmm whens the next update?:)
And I was wondering what the hell was going on with Frank, glad I finally know. :D

I KNEW IT.

You have no idea how loud I squealed when I saw that you updated. This is getting good. Hopefully Gerard can make Frank remember that burning flame of passion and love they have for eachother.

Look with your special eyes, Frank! That missing piece is in front of you.

Ok I'll stop. I'll be waiting for the next update! :D Good luck trying to put it together since I get how difficult and irritating it can be to transfer it from your head onto paper sometimes.

You updated!! I love you xD
Ah...so that explains why Frankie can't remember Gerard. Interesting...

More soon please?
<3

Ohgod, Frank was in a car accident and he can't remember? It's starting to fall together! Your tardiness with chapters are forgiven. <3 Update when you can/when you get the inspiration.

OMG =O So Frank can't remember because of an accident!? NOWWW it all makes sense. Okay it's kinda adorable that even though he can't remember Gerard, he still seemed to like him when he re met him. Oh how adorable! =D

heyyy there!I really liked the update and yay I did see that coming!can't wait to see what's next so yeah update as soon as you can :)

Totally didn't see that coming! But it makes complete sense! I'm still going with the notion that this is only the tip of the iceburg though, 'cause when Frank does remember, and his new found friend in Gerard, who does remember Frank, who may or may not say anything to him ('cause I mean really, what would you do in Gerard's situation?!), who apparently loved Frank...and oh my gosh, totally gives the words in the banner a whole new meaning! I know I go back to that a lot, but I can't help it. It's just wonderful, in my opinion and I rather like it...it fits. Like a really good one, like your favorite pair of jeans good (maybe I'm exaggerating, but whatever, I'm just expressing my thoughts). XD

And WOOO, an update!! :D I was so excited when I read the email notice for this. Best start to a new day. Seriously, yesterday was the worst ending to my weekend, I had an alergic reaction to my meds. So far, for a Monday, it's been awesome. Mostly due to this lovely update!

The wait was worth it, just sayin'. :)

Holy cow!! You're alive? :3 I like how there's a reason for Frank being weird now :( Sad, yet satisfying :D Update sooooooooooon :)

How can Frank just not remeber him?!
You ned to update soon!
I'm curious as to what Frank's reaction would be if he finds out it's really his Gerard if he doesn't remember.

Hey...
So I kind of, sort of, totally miss this story.
I will love you forever and ever if you updated soon.
I need to know what happens next!! D:
<3

I have been keeping track of updates for a bunch of weeks now. The suspense is seriously killing me D: And i'd really hate to see this wonderful fic abandoned :c Please update or at least let us know your alive.

xx
-Alice

Oh. Seems like updates haven't been happening in a while lol... well I hope that changes! :) Love this story. <3

Finally caught up! Wah I really wanna know what's up with Frankiepoo. And Gerard is so awkward. I see myself in him, which is totally not cute haha.
Update soon <3

agfjudgfajhgfadjga, UPDATE GODDAMNNIT

oh and also, I hope Frank isn't a douchebag. I don't want him to be mean or lying or arrogant. And I hope he wasn't lying before (in the prequel) about loving Gerard because that would just be a bit weird. Muhaha I can't wait to read the rest of it. Please update soon :) XOX

oh my goodness keep writing. for the love of all things good. I know it can be difficult sometimes to find the will to write, think up ideas and everything. But pleaaaaaasssssse write some more! :) I love this story and I need to know what happens. I'm sure that you as a writer also wants to know what happens. I can't really tell how this story is going to go, but I think somehow Gerard needs to reveal who he is, but not by simply telling Frank. Maybe he should subtly tell him the things he knows about him, like his parents, his hobbies, his favourite bands etc. Then Frank will be like wtf.

Ideas :DDDD i love this story so thank you for writing it XOXOX

First of all, I hope you did well on your exams! :)

Now, onto my two-cents: For some reason I really do have the notion that stuff is going to hit the fan. I'm glad Gerard's got the balls to finally confront Frank about what the heck is going on betwee 'em, 'cause good grief, we all want to know what the heck is going on, but I really still have the gut feeling those two itty bitty statements in the banner are not pleasantries. I could be wrong, but hey, who doesn't like a little angst filled drama every now and then? XD

No worries on the rambling front, I cannot help it...I've tried. I always feel like if I leave something out, the author's not getting their fill (I hope that makes sense). XD Regardless, I adored this update. Albeit small in size, it was enough to keep me wanting more and just enough interaction to speculate what could happen next. Though I'm certain I'm most likely wrong. I mean, unless Frank emotionally couldn't handle their last encounter and truly did "erase" Gerard from memory (or extremely repressed said memories), they HAVE to know who they're talking to. Unless it's a round-about way to "start over" in a sense. However, I'm still going to stick with my gut, I have a feeling that those two statements, the "but you loved me" is coming from Gerard and the "but you lied to me" is coming from Frank. I just have think inkling. XD

Meh, I'll just have to wait and see what happens during Gerard's lunch break! (Anxiously mind you) :)