I Don't Love You Like I Loved You Yesterday - Comments

  • Oh, and one last thing I didn't add yesterday:
    Gerard probably would have gone to jail. Sex with a minor still counts as 'rape', even if consent is given. So, in the eyes of the law, what Gerard did was still illegal. Sorry to be knit-picking, but I just thought you might want to know for future reference ...
    And admit it; I wouldn't be commenting and correcting the facts if I didn't love this story so much!! :D
    Honestly, it was such a great story, and different from any one that I've ever read. Congratulations.
    :hug: :arms:
    May 28th, 2009 at 05:27am
  • cemetery drive.:
    I know this story is kind of long over now, but I just wanted to comment anyway. I really liked it, along with its prequel which I also read. It was cute, romantic, funny, and sad, all in one story. You're an excellent writer. I guess the only criticism I could have with it was that I wouldn't really classify it as a Frerard, more as just an MCR fic with elements of Frerard. Though Frank and Gerard were together in the end, and did have an affair during the prequel, it was mainly based on the lives and relationships of Gerard/Ellie/Rosie/MCR, so this is why I wouldn't exactly call it a Frerard. I still loved it though, don't worry! I wouldn't be commenting if I didn't!
    So, with that said ~ don't be surprised if I end up subscribing to any other story of yours! Well done, and thank you!
    :hug: :arms:

    P.S. At first, I hated Ellie, because I thought she was Eliza Cuts, and you'd just given her a slightly different, alternative name (Ellie/El/Eleanor). But then I realised through the way you signed off the author's notes that she was actually you! (right?)
    I didn't hate her as much after that. Only a little bit, because she got in the way. tehe
    Thank you so much!
    Yeh, Ellie is based on me, not Eliza.

    xx
    May 27th, 2009 at 10:38pm
  • I know this story is kind of long over now, but I just wanted to comment anyway. I really liked it, along with its prequel which I also read. It was cute, romantic, funny, and sad, all in one story. You're an excellent writer. I guess the only criticism I could have with it was that I wouldn't really classify it as a Frerard, more as just an MCR fic with elements of Frerard. Though Frank and Gerard were together in the end, and did have an affair during the prequel, it was mainly based on the lives and relationships of Gerard/Ellie/Rosie/MCR, so this is why I wouldn't exactly call it a Frerard. I still loved it though, don't worry! I wouldn't be commenting if I didn't!
    So, with that said ~ don't be surprised if I end up subscribing to any other story of yours! Well done, and thank you!
    :hug: :arms:

    P.S. At first, I hated Ellie, because I thought she was Eliza Cuts, and you'd just given her a slightly different, alternative name (Ellie/El/Eleanor). But then I realised through the way you signed off the author's notes that she was actually you! (right?)
    I didn't hate her as much after that. Only a little bit, because she got in the way. tehe
    May 27th, 2009 at 03:41pm
  • oohhhhhhhh!! it ended.
    as would mark hoppus say: it's finland:D
    I actually cried when they said their goodbyes to Ellie but I'm glad Gee's moved on, and OMG i want a sequel.^^"
    it was just so... realistic I suppose. and really fantastic<33
    so I'm giving you the wanted comment (well I hope it's wanted^^') and say I love you!<33
    Emilyxox.
    April 4th, 2009 at 04:12pm
  • i know this is a bit late but i just came across the story about last week and im just now finishing it! wow serioulsy this is the first story to ever make me cry!

    i loved it!!!
    February 5th, 2009 at 06:03am
  • that was beautiful. you should be so proud of yourself!
    February 1st, 2009 at 09:00pm
  • cute ending
    January 16th, 2009 at 04:57am
  • loved the ending! It was very well written in my opinion xD
    January 15th, 2009 at 02:09pm
  • soo.
    i was really behind on this story, the last thing i read was mikey having his kid. lol.
    soo i just read the rest, and i admit it, i cried.
    omg.
    poor El.
    Poor Gee actually.
    But I'm happy at how it ended. =]
    They were so cute together.
    <3
    January 10th, 2009 at 08:25am
  • Aw, what an adorable ending.
    Frank and Gerard were destined to be together and it's nice that Ellie said he could be.
    Poor Rosie with her drugs =(
    But a perfect messed up happy ending ;)
    January 9th, 2009 at 10:48pm
  • I'm really sorry, but I won't be writing a sequel...
    Please don't hate me forever.

    El;;;XD
    January 6th, 2009 at 08:17pm
  • EHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH KILL ME NOW!
    i loved it!! ur the bestestest writer ever!! im so sad its over just like that! dammit i wish you could have dragged on the last few chapters.. like ellie died so suddenly NOOO and frank came back into the picture pretty randomly there wasnt much emotion came across as a rebound. hah! and the rosie wtf i missed the whole drug age and how she coped with frank and gerard and all the sex scenes we missed and revealing it all to rosie about her sister and the twins and ohmyfuck to soon!!! im mad at you now! ok no im not but grr dont end story!!!

    I lloved it too much.
    January 6th, 2009 at 02:05pm
  • AHHHH!!!
    You ENDED it!!!
    It's...It's...It's OVER!!!
    -tear-
    I'm gonna miss this story!!!
    ...I can't believe it's all done!!!
    Will you be doing another sequal???

    LOVED IT!!
    January 6th, 2009 at 08:01am
  • ^ I'd like to know too

    I don't think there was enough of Frank in it.
    It would be nice for more, but I suppose it all depends on the last chapter.
    Can't wait. =)
    xoxoxo
    January 5th, 2009 at 06:10pm
  • Aww:]
    Quick question though.
    Are you gonna continue the story after the ending of this one?
    January 5th, 2009 at 10:33am
  • Aww that was sad...

    “I’m not ready… I can’t… I’m sorry…,” I backed out of the room, trying not to cry again, running back to my car.
    Poor Frankie...But poor Gerard too

    Oooo Gerard's taking Rosie back to live at home!
    Yay Gerard for finally starting to move on!

    “Don’t forget her… I love Ricci as a daughter, but she’s your daughter Gee. Don’t forget to visit her once in a while…
    Awww =(
    So sad..
    But Jeri has a point..it's not fair for Gerard to ignore Ricci like he is

    I grinned to myself, and got in the car.
    “Yeh, maybe I will see him around sometime.”

    EEKK!
    Yay!
    This is good, Gerard would make Ellie proud by starting to continue with his life!!

    Update Soon Please!!!
    January 4th, 2009 at 09:46pm
  • AH, NO NOT THE END OF THE STORYYY. NOOOO.
    sorry, caps attack.
    Anyway. Brilliant, Frank attack and all. Poor Rosie though. Imagine being that young and losing your parents... that'd suck to say the least.
    January 4th, 2009 at 07:21pm
  • *LEGASP*
    FRANKS BACCCKKKK :D:D:D:D
    ^ ^
    nomnomnom. Feel sorry for Gee, but... Frank! *dances*
    January 3rd, 2009 at 09:52pm
  • EEKKK!!
    -hug-
    Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU!!
    WOOHOO FRANKIE's BACK!!!
    xD
    Ah, this is so kewl!
    I is bad..my eyes kinda droped and I say Franks name before I finnised the update..
    lol safe to say it made me read faster =P
    Ooooo what's gonna happen?! What'll be said?!
    I can't wait!!

    PLEASE! Update Soon!!!
    January 3rd, 2009 at 09:05pm
  • Awwww
    Wow 7 months!!
    Dx Whats happened to Frankie?
    Last we heard of him he'd run away!!
    Ek, someone cheer Gerard up!
    His mums otta point though...7 mothns is a LONG time....she should starr moving on now..
    I liked how he heard Ellie at the end =)
    Nice touch!

    More Soon?
    January 3rd, 2009 at 03:49pm