Two is Better than One

The title says it all.
Hayley Anderson was forced to study in a school called Werverd High by her mom. Mainly because she was offered a scholarship because she's good at sports. She never wanted to accept it until her best friend, Dylan Johnson, did a sacrifice of going with her.
Thanks to Werverd, she's now struggling between two loves - the one that's she's afraid to face and the one that's really forbidden,
What should she pick?