The Echo Never Fades - Comments

So I FINALLY got home and got to read the rest of this. I really can't say much, because I just don't know what to say, but it's amazing. And the songs were ALL so perfect, but the last one on Gerard's chapter was definitely pretty incredible. I just really don't know what to say. You're truly and amazing writer.

The Way:

This is what you did to me.

I am a terrible, horrible person. :mrgreen:

This is what you did to me.

Gerard Arthur Rush Way, I love you! If you dare leave us like that in reality, well... the MCRmy will follow you. :sigh:

Sorry, I had to say it. As you guessed, I'm sobbing again. NOTHING has made me cry like this, ever. Fights with parents or friends last only like, less than an hour. Even at my grandma's death, I only teared up. This is making me cry repeatedly, and it's almost been a week since I read the first chapter.

Actually, I heard it was only twelve bucks last month...maybe it's the power bill that's high...I don't remember; I'm not the one paying for it.

horsie890:

Cynical Chick:

No way.

I've never cried over any story, ever, Until I read this. Each account of what happened was heart-wrenching, And the description....My, god!

The music was so beautiful, I'm going to track it down and get if off of Limewire right now.

Just the thought of Gerard Way, killed publicly was enough to make me start bawling, and vomit at the same time.

You are a amazing writer. Please keep writing, and I have one question....Does this story have reader-insurance?

:)

Reader insurance? That's not a half bad idea! Unfortunately, if I had to account for all the tears this story has caused, my water bill would be through the roof (as if it's not already, thanks to living in Vegas).

Oh yes, I'd expect that bill to be high :)

Cynical Chick:

No way.

I've never cried over any story, ever, Until I read this. Each account of what happened was heart-wrenching, And the description....My, god!

The music was so beautiful, I'm going to track it down and get if off of Limewire right now.

Just the thought of Gerard Way, killed publicly was enough to make me start bawling, and vomit at the same time.

You are a amazing writer. Please keep writing, and I have one question....Does this story have reader-insurance?

:)

Reader insurance? That's not a half bad idea! Unfortunately, if I had to account for all the tears this story has caused, my water bill would be through the roof (as if it's not already, thanks to living in Vegas).

No way.

I've never cried over any story, ever, Until I read this. Each account of what happened was heart-wrenching, And the description....My, god!

The music was so beautiful, I'm going to track it down and get if off of Limewire right now.

Just the thought of Gerard Way, killed publicly was enough to make me start bawling, and vomit at the same time.

You are a amazing writer. Please keep writing, and I have one question....Does this story have reader-insurance?

:)

If you look closely enough, the translations are already there
But here they are anyway.

Ciao.
Hello.

È buono per vederla. Anche se non abbiamo mai incontrato, chi so lei è.
It's good to see you. Even though you've never met, I know who you are.

Perdonarme, per favore.
Forgive me, please.

Romanza
Romance (...as far as I know. I'm not entirely sure. By the way, the similarity between this and the MCR song was a complete accident. It scared me into complete shock when I first heard it.)

Bell’anche nella morte.
Beautiful even in death.

Il mio Idillio Chimico.
My Chemical Romance. (See why I'm not sure about the word Romanza?)

il mio amico
my friend

Ciao.
Goodbye.

Ciao means either hello or goodbye, depending on the context. That's the extent of the Italian I know...and I never would have been able to do any of this without linda.'s help.

wow...best story ever. so heart toucing

out of intrest, what does the italian translate into?

So I did find the time to read chapter two before I left, and it's amazing. What else can I say? I'll read the rest when I get back later today ;D

lups:

oh yeah, and now im going to read The Tragic Tale of The Black Parade...

I hope you like it. I spent a lot of time making it as good as I possibly could, just like I did on this story.

I am my own 50th comment. :mrgreen:

oh yeah, and now im going to read The Tragic Tale of The Black Parade...

*falls at your feet crying the hell out* BE PROUD, you are officially the first person who makes me cry with a story. All the chapters are great, but the Gerard's one.... Oh my God, was THE BEST. The most sad and nostalgic, and WOW when he said 'I start playing the song again' and it actually started the song again in the music player!!! I was like O__O 'whoa Gee!!' YOU ARE THE BEST MCR WRITER IVE EVER READ. honestly....

I've always pictured Black Parade Gerard as a very formal person compared to him normally. This is clearly shown in my fic The Tragic Tale Of The Black Parade. You'd like it...except for-
You know what? Just read it and I won't ruin it for you.

I guess... But there's something about the way he talked. It was so... formal, and kind of unlike him.

I miss him already. :(

Would it change your mind if I said it was because death changes people?

Tears are clouding my sight and dripping from my eyes as I write this. When I read Bob's, I only got teary-eyed. Then I saw another chapter and knew it was coming. Did it surprise you that Gerard's POV broke my heart?

Truthfully, I didn't like your characterization of him too much - too... perfect, I think. And even he isn't that; I acknowledge it.

Wait... I'm crying again...

So, okay. I appreciate the romance with the ballerina and the not wanting to come back anymore (though I believe he'd think otherwise), but it was the part with Mikey... again. Brotherly fics thoroughly tear me up, and this was no exception.

I'm not yet done crying. This story is so appropriately named, because it echoes in my mind and leaves me sobbing at night. I wish I can prove it by showing you pics of my teary face, but the camera is nowhere in sight. Just so you know, the first chapter is still the best. :)

best story i have ever read. truly

no no no no
YOU LITTLE... LADY!!! you made me cry now. for real. 4 chapter holding my tears, and now i failed. POOR BOB!! ='[ omg theyre all so sad... you know what i like about this story? that Gerard didn't suicide, as most of us would expect. he was murdered, which adds it a whole load of frustration because it was out of their hands... i love it.

i still can't enter ficwad!! GRR

oh, and that was a good spanish up there. I live in mexico, you knew that??