OMG I need the sequel right now!!! I have so many emotions about this story I feel so as for john right now not that I'm excusing his behavior about messing around on Jenna but he should just be honest with her.
I'm not a fan of Jonathan at the end, here. He played with Madison and her emotions while still with his girlfriend. That's shitty behavior towards both Madison and Jenna. He chased after Madison without breaking up with Jenna first. Regardless of how much he says he loves madison, that's completely uncool. You don't emotionally fuck around on your girlfriend and you certainly don't kiss old exes, 'true' love or not.
As much as I love happy endings, I'm glad that this is the way this one ended. I only started reading this a few weeks ago, but I can honestly say that it was one of my favorite stories and I can't wait to read the sequel to find out what happens next and where you'll pick up.
This fanfic is too much for me. The fact that it brought tears to my eyes, and a story hasn't done that for me in such a long time, is amazing. Even just the strong anticipation I've had for this fanfic is overwhelming- I cannot explain the happiness I feel when this is updated. I'm so sad that the end is coming, but your fanfic took me on a wonderful journey, so it was all worth it.
Thank you for writing one of the best fanfics I've ever read, gurl, and I'll be looking forward to your James Neal story. (P.S. I love your Tyler Seguin story too.)